You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
docs(quick-260428-rsu): re-defer pending maintainer response on 725/726
Resumed quick task after PR nolabs-ai#785 (claude-pack-migration) merged
upstream on 2026-04-29 — fired trigger #1 in CONTEXT.md `<deferred>`
block. Sigstore-bump triggers (nolabs-ai#777, nolabs-ai#778) are dead (PRs closed).
Rebase attempt via `git rebase --onto upstream/main 063ebad
origin/v2.0-pr` surfaced 77 conflicts across 504 upstream commits
(v0.41 → v0.44):
- 49 UU content conflicts
- 26 AA add/add (16 of which are `crates/nono-cli/src/*_runtime.rs` —
parallel-evolution architectural collision; common ancestor has
none of them, both branches added independently with different
content)
- 2 DU (policy_cmd.rs upstream-deleted per nolabs-ai#594, needs remap onto
split policy.rs / network_policy.rs / deprecated_policy.rs)
Aborted the rebase rather than improvise architectural decisions on
upstream's runtime refactor. Posted deferential outreach comments
on PR nolabs-ai#725 and nolabs-ai#726 asking the maintainer to pick between (1) push
through rebase with inline guidance, (2) close+restage as smaller
per-phase PRs, or (3) alternate path.
Comments:
- nolabs-ai#725 (comment)
- nolabs-ai#726 (comment)
Re-deferred until maintainer response. Locked decisions from
2026-04-28 still hold (phase22 stays on local main; force-push gate
never crossed; windows-squash untouched).
Signed-off-by: oscarmackjr-twg <oscar.mack.jr@gmail.com>
| Human reviewer engagement on 725/726 | None yet (10 automated reviews on #725, 2 on #726, no human comments) |
38
+
| 2026-05-12 soft deadline | Not yet reached |
31
39
32
-
The runbook executes when ANY of these fires:
40
+
The "wait-for-#785-and-sigstore" timing decision was structured as OR semantics in CONTEXT.md `<deferred>` block; #785's firing alone is sufficient to authorize execution. The sigstore-bump trigger is now permanently dead (companion v2.3 audit-attestation hardening sweep loses one of its planned unblocks).
2.**PRs #777 and #778 both merge on upstream** — sigstore bump trigger
36
-
3.**A human reviewer on always-further/nono engages** — submits CHANGES_REQUESTED or APPROVED on PR 725 or PR 726
37
-
4.**2026-05-12** — soft deadline; if no triggers fire, escalate (re-evaluate timing decision)
42
+
## Rebase attempt (2026-04-29) — aborted at conflict checkpoint
38
43
39
-
When triggered, run:
44
+
Approach: switched from runbook's `git apply --3way --index` (failed atomically due to binary-file index errors — `AGENTS.md.bundle: does not exist in index`) to canonical `git rebase --onto upstream/main 063ebad6 origin/v2.0-pr` for the single squashed commit. Same target outcome, more robust binary handling.
40
45
41
-
```
42
-
/gsd-quick resume refresh-stack-onto-upstream-tip
43
-
```
46
+
### Drift quantified
47
+
48
+
-**504 upstream commits** between v2.0-pr's old merge-base (`063ebad6`) and current upstream tip (`34725154`)
-**#594** — Consolidated `nono policy` subcommands under `nono profile` (deprecation alias + relocation; killed `policy_cmd.rs`, split into `policy.rs` / `network_policy.rs` / `deprecated_policy.rs`)
52
+
-**#785** — Moved `claude-code` and `codex` builtin profiles into package-registry-pack format
53
+
- Workspace version 0.30.1 → 0.44.0; new default `system-keyring` feature flag
54
+
55
+
### Conflict scope: 77 files
56
+
57
+
| Type | Count | Notes |
58
+
|---|---|---|
59
+
|`UU` content | 49 | Includes all CONTEXT.md watchlist files: `cli.rs`, `Cargo.toml`, `profile/builtin.rs`, `data/policy.json`, `nono-proxy/src/reverse.rs`|
60
+
|`AA` add/add | 26 |**16 of these are `crates/nono-cli/src/*_runtime.rs`** — common ancestor `063ebad6` does NOT contain these files; both upstream and v2.0-pr added them independently with different content. Architectural collision, not drift. |
61
+
|`DU` delete/modified | 2 |`policy_cmd.rs` and `tests/policy_cmd.rs` upstream-deleted (per #594); v2.0-pr's modifications need remap onto split structure |
62
+
63
+
### Key finding: AA cluster is parallel-evolution, not simple add/add
64
+
65
+
Probe via `git ls-tree`:
66
+
-`crates/nono-cli/src/command_runtime.rs` does not exist in `063ebad6` (common ancestor)
67
+
- Upstream/main adds it as blob `4fb78ea0`
68
+
- v2.0-pr adds it as blob `d288f547`
69
+
70
+
Conclusion: upstream did the same runtime refactor v2.0-pr did, but with different specifics. Each of the 16 runtime files needs architectural review against its upstream counterpart rather than textual merge — beyond the runbook's "drift-only" scope assumption.
71
+
72
+
### Rebase aborted cleanly
73
+
74
+
-`git rebase --abort` ran; `v2.0-pr-rebase-260428` staging branch deleted
75
+
-`main` HEAD restored to `a9c92200` (Phase 23 work intact)
76
+
- Working tree clean (only the same untracked items present at task start)
77
+
- No origin pushes occurred — `--force-with-lease` gate never crossed
78
+
79
+
## Outreach posted 2026-04-29
80
+
81
+
Comments posted to both PRs requesting maintainer direction:
The comments offer three paths and ask the maintainer to pick one:
44
87
45
-
The resume path loads CONTEXT.md (decisions stay LOCKED) and reads PLAN.md as the runbook. The decisions made on 2026-04-28 do not need to be revisited unless triggers go stale.
88
+
1. Push through the rebase as-is (with maintainer input on architectural conflicts inline)
89
+
2. Close 725/726 and reopen as a per-phase PR series against current upstream
90
+
3. Different approach the maintainer prefers
46
91
47
-
## Files produced
92
+
## Re-deferral conditions
48
93
49
-
-`260428-rsu-CONTEXT.md` — decisions locked; this is the durable artifact
50
-
-`260428-rsu-PLAN.md` — 5-task git runbook (Tasks 1-5: rebase v2.0-pr, rebase v2.1-pr, smoke-test, force-push, cleanup)
51
-
-`260428-rsu-SUMMARY.md` — this file
94
+
This task is now blocked on maintainer response. Re-resume when ANY of:
52
95
53
-
## No commits to source code
96
+
1.**Maintainer comments on #725 or #726 with a directional answer** — execute that direction (rebase, close-and-restage, or alternate)
97
+
2.**Maintainer takes a substantive action on either PR** (review submitted, label change, close, etc.) — re-evaluate scope
98
+
3.**2026-05-12 soft deadline still applies** — if no maintainer response by then, escalate (consider closing PRs and committing fully to the v2.2-merged-into-main flow)
54
99
55
-
Per the deferred status, no source-code commits land in this quick task. Only `.planning/quick/260428-rsu-*` artifacts.
100
+
## What did NOT happen today
56
101
57
-
## Decisions deferred for the resume run (NOT pre-locked)
102
+
- No source-code commits landed (rebase aborted; no force-push)
103
+
- Phase 22 + 23 work on local `main` is unchanged (held per locked `phase22_disposition: hold-local-until-merge`)
104
+
-`windows-squash` source-of-truth branch is untouched (read-only per locked decision)
58
105
59
-
These are intentionally Claude's discretion at execute time, since they're mechanical and trigger-specific:
106
+
## Files produced (cumulative)
60
107
61
-
-Branch naming for working branches (`v2.0-pr-rebase-{date}` etc.)
62
-
-Cherry-pick vs `git apply --3way` for the squash regeneration mechanism
63
-
-Whether to delete old origin tips post-push (default: yes, git reflog covers archaeology)
0 commit comments