Pre-registration Feedback

[ShreshthSaxena]

Completeness (all sections completed and organized according to template): 1/1

Clarity (external readers can understand your design and have enough details to replicate it): 5.6/6

• Excellent job at the background and introduction!
• Given that you have two multi-level factors, you could have designed multiple hypothesis from your data.
• Randomisation should also be counterbalanced but that wasn't described.
• Justification for the chosen effect size in power analysis was not provided
• Using ball players and video gamers as visual experts is a smart decision but more justification or explanation about the expected differences in their visual expertise would've been great.

Novelty and logic (your experiment contributes something new to the literature and is logically designed): 3/3

• the study topic and design are well thought of.