Purpose
Revalidate the review-only recommendation tiering logic after GOAL-REC-TIERING-01, under explicit user authorization, without creating live or actionable recommendation outputs.
Dependency gate
Do not start unless all are true:
Issue GOAL-REC-TIERING-01 Review-Only Recommendation Score Tiering Gate #10 project-current.
Post-merge validation passes.
The review-only tiering contract is accepted.
The User explicitly authorizes GOAL-10B.4.
If any condition is false, stop and report BLOCKED. Do not self-unlock.
Base branch
Latest authoritative project-current only.
Suggested work branch
codex-max/goal10b4-revalidation
Scope
Revalidation only. Evaluate robustness, warning propagation, sensitivity, and failure conditions of the review-only tiering/recommendation scoring chain.
Hard boundaries
No BUY/SELL/HOLD.
No target price.
No live recommendation row.
No actual position size, target weight, portfolio weight, or order quantity.
No dashboard/frontend.
No trading, broker, production, local-lake, factor-mining, or DQN/RL.
No automatic unlock of position-band validation.
Required analysis
out-of-sample or contract-approved revalidation
sensitivity to thresholds and regime composition
warning propagation
provider/data-quality concentration
weak-signal and calibration diagnostics
failure attribution sufficient to decide whether later position-band work is eligible
Validation
Full project validation stack plus fresh-clone verification. Confirm no forbidden outputs are created.
Required outputs
Implementation / tests / config / docs / audit / manifest / report / handoff sufficient for reproducible review.
Final response
Goal status / Branch / Commit / Base / Validation / Revalidation findings / Blocking warnings / Non-blocking warnings / Boundary confirmation / Recommended next action.
Human action required
Humans review only the standardized summary and explicit eligibility decision for any later position-band validation.
Purpose
Revalidate the review-only recommendation tiering logic after GOAL-REC-TIERING-01, under explicit user authorization, without creating live or actionable recommendation outputs.
Dependency gate
Do not start unless all are true:
project-current.If any condition is false, stop and report BLOCKED. Do not self-unlock.
Base branch
Latest authoritative
project-currentonly.Suggested work branch
codex-max/goal10b4-revalidationScope
Revalidation only. Evaluate robustness, warning propagation, sensitivity, and failure conditions of the review-only tiering/recommendation scoring chain.
Hard boundaries
Required analysis
Validation
Full project validation stack plus fresh-clone verification. Confirm no forbidden outputs are created.
Required outputs
Implementation / tests / config / docs / audit / manifest / report / handoff sufficient for reproducible review.
Final response
Goal status / Branch / Commit / Base / Validation / Revalidation findings / Blocking warnings / Non-blocking warnings / Boundary confirmation / Recommended next action.
Human action required
Humans review only the standardized summary and explicit eligibility decision for any later position-band validation.