Best practice for deploying multiple brokers with security settings?

[andr0272]

I am trying to deploy an operator with 3 brokers, and a security configuration using the ActiveMQAtremisSecurity CR. When I run this deployment I get a persistent warning on all 3 brokers saying "There are more than one servers on the network broadcasting the same node id". This seems to only happen when I deploy the brokers simultaneously. If I deploy a single broker with this configuration, than scale up by reapplying the ActiveMQArtemis CR with spec.deploymentPlan.size: 3, I get 3 seperate NodeIDs. Has anyone encountered this?
Edit: Version 1.0.5

[brusdev]

@andr0272 can you reproduce this issue on 1.0.7 and share your ActiveMQArtemis CR with the relative logs?

[andr0272]

Updating to 1.0.8 resolved my issue.
Thank you for your guidance, sorry for leaving this open so long.
Best!

[brusdev]

@andr0272 thanks for your feedback

[Emmett-42]

Hi, I get this issue as well. I'm using the 2.1.4 version on my openshift cluster as the operator deployment.
WARN` [org.apache.activemq.artemis.core.client] AMQ212034: There are more than one servers on the network broadcasting the same node id.
twice every few minutes on the ss-0 and the ss-1 pod keeps gracefully shutting down and restarting. the PVC are different. and when I scale down to 1 and then back to 2, the issue is still there, it doesn't recreate the nodeIDs.
any suggestions? what could be the cause of this. I also get reconcilation errors in the controller manager, could it be related to this - for the pod restarts?

[brusdev]

@Emmett-42 Apache Artemis reads the nodeID from the journal. If you see this error, it means that different PVCs include a journal with the same nodeID. You need to clean up or delete the affected PVCs.