Skip to content

vector-backend-policy.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
74 lines (59 loc) · 3.44 KB

vector-backend-policy.md

File metadata and controls

74 lines (59 loc) · 3.44 KB
Raw

Vector Backend Policy

ai-memory currently stores embeddings as packed vectors in SQLite and does brute-force cosine over latest pages at query time. sqlite-vec is deferred intentionally, not rejected.

Why Not sqlite-vec Yet?

The expected corpus is usually hundreds to low-thousands of latest wiki pages per project. At that size, brute-force cosine is simple, inspectable, and fast enough, especially because vector retrieval is only one signal in the query path. memory_query already combines FTS5, lexical entity matching, graph-neighbor expansion, optional vector RRF, and raw observation fallback. Each stream contributes through the same bounded candidate window, then a page-authority adjustment runs after fusion, so semantic similarity cannot by itself declare a session page more canonical than a maintained decision.

Adding sqlite-vec would add operational surface before it has proven value:

  • Extension loading must work consistently on every SQLite connection.
  • Docker/static-link packaging must stay reliable across target hosts.
  • Startup diagnostics need to distinguish extension-load failures from embedding provider/model/dim drift.
  • Derived vector tables need safe rebuild/backfill paths.
  • Prior-art projects hit real bugs around native vector dependencies, extension loading, and silent embedding skips.

For now, regular SQLite rows keep the vector contract simple: markdown is source of truth, page_embeddings is durable derived data, and status can report missing embeddings or provider/model/dim heterogeneity without a second index format.

When To Add sqlite-vec

Add sqlite-vec when measurements show brute-force vector scoring is the bottleneck and vectors materially improve retrieval quality.

Concrete trigger criteria:

  • Latest embedded pages per project regularly exceed roughly 5k-10k.
  • memory_query p95 exceeds roughly 150-250ms locally because of vector scoring, after FTS/graph paths are already optimized.
  • Profiling shows query-time dot products consume meaningful CPU, especially under concurrent MCP calls.
  • Real retrieval evals show vector results improve recall over FTS5 + entity + graph by a meaningful margin, for example +5-10% recall@5.
  • A migration can create and backfill the vec table from existing page_embeddings without resetting user data.
  • The derived vector index can be dropped and rebuilt from markdown + page_embeddings; repair must never delete source wiki files.
  • Docker packaging and startup checks fail clearly when the extension is unavailable.

Non-Criteria

Do not add sqlite-vec just because vector databases are conventional, or because it feels architecturally cleaner. Without measured latency or recall pressure, the extra dependency and repair surface are not worth it.

Intended Shape When It Lands

sqlite-vec should remain a derived index behind the existing embedding contract. It should not become the source of truth and should not change the MCP tool surface. The migration path should be additive:

  1. Keep page_embeddings as durable metadata and vector storage.
  2. Add a vec virtual table populated from page_embeddings.
  3. Teach diagnostics to report vec-table row counts and stale rows.
  4. Add a safe rebuild command/path for the derived vec table.
  5. Switch vector candidate generation from brute-force scan to sqlite-vec, while preserving FTS5 + entity + graph + vector RRF semantics. The existing post-fusion authority adjustment remains unchanged.