Skip to content

decoherence_analysis.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
62 lines (51 loc) · 3.29 KB

decoherence_analysis.md

File metadata and controls

62 lines (51 loc) · 3.29 KB
Raw

Decoherence Analysis — grug_comprehensive_full.specimen

Issues Found

1. have_faith → should be "trust" (thesaurus synonym leak)

Turn 8: "It is care and have_faith and wanting good for another"

  • The thesaurus maps "trust" → aliases including "have_faith", but the engine picked the alias instead of the canonical
  • FIX: Remove "have_faith" from thesaurus, or ensure the system_prompt uses the word "trust" directly

2. "Grug spin to greeting" — nonsense phrase (Turn 2)

  • The AIML orchestrator is generating "Grug spin to greeting" from some rule or template
  • "spin to" is not meaningful English
  • This appears to be from the template construction where it substitutes the lobe name
  • FIX: This is an engine behavior — need to check if it's from AIML template interpolation

3. "Grug articulate of fire" — wrong verb (Turn 24)

  • "articulate of" is not proper Grug-speak
  • Should be "speak of" or "think on"
  • Appears to be thesaurus/verb_registry substituting "articulate" for "speak"

4. "Adore" instead of "Love" (Turn 25)

  • Multipart question "what is love and what is courage" → response uses "Adore" instead of "Love"
  • Thesaurus is replacing the canonical word with an alias
  • FIX: The thesaurus should not override the primary topic word in the response

5. Multipart questions only answer ONE part (Turns 23-25)

  • "what is fire and what is water" → only answers about fire
  • "why does fire burn and why does water flow" → only answers about fire
  • "what is love and what is courage" → only answers about love
  • Known issue: InputDecomposer splits but voting pipeline only produces votes from one sub-subject
  • Partial fix: Decomposer config needs to work, and multipart orchestrator needs both parts scored

6. "Grug title grammar" — wrong verb (Turn 41)

  • Should be "Grug speak of grammar" or similar
  • Another thesaurus leak — "title" is not a verb that fits here

7. Some known topics get "Nothing in the cave" responses

  • "what is truth" — no node for "truth"
  • "i feel sad" — no node for "sad" (only "sadness")
  • "i am afraid" — no node for "afraid" (only "fear")
  • "who are you" — no node for identity
  • "what is physics" — no node for "physics"
  • "what is biology" — no node for "biology"
  • "what is civilization" — no node for "civilization"
  • FIX: Add missing single-token nodes for these concepts

8. Algebra response has empty prefix before "The relation" (Turn 14)

  • "Here is the picture: The relation: algebra finds unknowns."
  • Double space + missing content before "The relation"
  • The AIML scaffold is inserting the relational triple without proper prefix content

9. /answer mechanic: Step 1 fails — existing nodes fire before hippocampal ask

  • "what is photosynthesis" matches the "photosynthesis" node already in the specimen (science lobe)
  • "what is the derivative of x squared" matches "derivative" node (mathematics lobe)
  • "what is chlorophyll" matches "photosynthesis" node (via chlorophyll content)
  • The /answer test questions are hitting EXISTING nodes, so no ask is generated
  • FIX: Use topics that truly have NO nodes for the /answer test

10. "righteous noise" instead of "just noise" (Turn 41)

  • "Without grammar words are righteous noise"
  • "righteous" doesn't fit — should be "just" or "mere"
  • Thesaurus/verb substitution issue