@@ -313,12 +313,12 @@ Real-time dependability cannot be achieved by buying faster clock speeds or meas
313313![ ] ( figures/fig04_real_industrial_ethercat_controller.jpg ) {width="85%"}
314314:::
315315
316- | Interconnect Protocol | Physical Topology & Signaling | Payload Throughput ($\beta$) | Transfer Latency & Cycle Jitter | Determinism Classification | Physical Reach & Wiring Harness | Physical AI Subsystem Placement |
317- | :-------------------------------------------------------------| :-------------------------------------------------------------------------| :------------------------------------------------------------------------------------| :---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | :------------------------------------------------------------| :-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------| :------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
318- | ** SPI** (Serial Peripheral Interface) | Synchronous 4-wire full-duplex (SCLK, MOSI, MISO, CS), point-to-point | $10\text{--}50\text{ Mbps}$ (up to $80\text{ Mbps}$ in QSPI/OSPI) | Latency: $0.5\text{--}2.0\, \mu\text{s}$ \newline Jitter: $< 50\text{ ns}$ | ** Bounded** (cycle-deterministic register reads) | $< 0.3\text{ m}$ (intra-board PCB traces / flat flex) | Joint magnetic angle encoders, 3-phase current-sense ADCs, gate drivers |
319- | ** CAN-FD** (Controller Area Network FD) | 2-wire differential multidrop with bitwise priority arbitration | $1\text{ Mbps}$ arbitration, $5\text{--}8\text{ Mbps}$ data phase (64-byte payload) | Latency: $$ 25\text{--}150\,\mu\text{s} $$ \newline Jitter: $$$ 10\text{--}50\, \mu\text{s}$$ | ** Analytically Bounded** (strictly bounded for top IDs) | $\le 40\text{ m}$ at $1\text{ Mbps}$ / $\le 15\text{ m}$ at $5\text{ Mbps}$ (twisted pair) | Chassis management, battery management systems (BMS), auxiliary actuators |
320- | ** EtherCAT** (Ethernet Control Automation) | 100BASE-TX full-duplex daisy-chain; on-the-fly hardware frame processing | $100\text{ Mbps}$ ($1\text{ Gbps}$ in EtherCAT G), payload efficiency $>90\% $ | Latency: $1.0\text{--}5.0\, \mu\text{s}$ per node \newline Jitter: $< 100\text{ ns}$ (distributed clocks) | ** Hard Real-Time** (hardware-scheduled cyclic PDO frames) | $\le 100\text{ m}$ between nodes (shielded Cat5e/Cat6) | Multi-axis robot arm joint servos, high-rate force-torque sensors |
321- | ** TSN Ethernet** (IEEE 802.1Qbv / Time-Sensitive Networking) | Star/mesh switched Ethernet with time-aware traffic shapers | $1\text{--}10\text{ Gbps}$ full-duplex | Latency: $$$ 10\text{--}50\, \mu\text{s}$ $ (scheduled slots) \newline Jitter: $< 1.0\, \mu\text{s}$ (PTP / IEEE 802.1AS) | ** Scheduled Deterministic** (time-gated queue transmission) | $\le 100\text{ m}$ per link | Centralized backbone bridging multi-camera vision, lidar, and safety reflexes |
316+ | Interconnect Protocol | Physical Topology & Signaling | Payload Throughput ($\beta$) | Transfer Latency & Cycle Jitter | Determinism Classification | Physical Reach & Wiring Harness | Physical AI Subsystem Placement |
317+ | :-------------------------------------------------------------| :-------------------------------------------------------------------------| :------------------------------------------------------------------------------------| :-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------| :------------------------------------------------------------| :-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------| :------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
318+ | ** SPI** (Serial Peripheral Interface) | Synchronous 4-wire full-duplex (SCLK, MOSI, MISO, CS), point-to-point | $10\text{--}50\text{ Mbps}$ (up to $80\text{ Mbps}$ in QSPI/OSPI) | Latency: $0.5\text{--}2.0\, \mu\text{s}$ \newline Jitter: $< 50\text{ ns}$ | ** Bounded** (cycle-deterministic register reads) | $< 0.3\text{ m}$ (intra-board PCB traces / flat flex) | Joint magnetic angle encoders, 3-phase current-sense ADCs, gate drivers |
319+ | ** CAN-FD** (Controller Area Network FD) | 2-wire differential multidrop with bitwise priority arbitration | $1\text{ Mbps}$ arbitration, $5\text{--}8\text{ Mbps}$ data phase (64-byte payload) | Latency: $25\text{--}150\, \mu\text{s}$ \newline Jitter: $10\text{--}50\, \mu\text{s}$ | ** Analytically Bounded** (strictly bounded for top IDs) | $\le 40\text{ m}$ at $1\text{ Mbps}$ / $\le 15\text{ m}$ at $5\text{ Mbps}$ (twisted pair) | Chassis management, battery management systems (BMS), auxiliary actuators |
320+ | ** EtherCAT** (Ethernet Control Automation) | 100BASE-TX full-duplex daisy-chain; on-the-fly hardware frame processing | $100\text{ Mbps}$ ($1\text{ Gbps}$ in EtherCAT G), payload efficiency $>90\% $ | Latency: $1.0\text{--}5.0\, \mu\text{s}$ per node \newline Jitter: $< 100\text{ ns}$ (distributed clocks) | ** Hard Real-Time** (hardware-scheduled cyclic PDO frames) | $\le 100\text{ m}$ between nodes (shielded Cat5e/Cat6) | Multi-axis robot arm joint servos, high-rate force-torque sensors |
321+ | ** TSN Ethernet** (IEEE 802.1Qbv / Time-Sensitive Networking) | Star/mesh switched Ethernet with time-aware traffic shapers | $1\text{--}10\text{ Gbps}$ full-duplex | Latency: $10\text{--}50\, \mu\text{s}$ (scheduled slots) \newline Jitter: $< 1.0\, \mu\text{s}$ (PTP / IEEE 802.1AS) | ** Scheduled Deterministic** (time-gated queue transmission) | $\le 100\text{ m}$ per link | Centralized backbone bridging multi-camera vision, lidar, and safety reflexes |
322322: ** Fieldbus and Interconnect Protocol Trade-Off Matrix for Physical AI Subsystems** : Comparative breakdown of physical signaling, bandwidth, transfer latency, cycle jitter, determinism classification, physical reach, and canonical subsystem placement across robotics interconnects. SPI provides sub-microsecond register access within a single board; CAN-FD provides robust priority-arbitrated messaging across chassis wiring; EtherCAT delivers microsecond-level hardware cycle synchronization across distributed joint motor drives; and TSN Ethernet unifies high-bandwidth vision streams with scheduled real-time control frames over a single physical backbone. {#tbl-04-fieldbus-comparison}
323323
324324<!-- END -->
0 commit comments