Skip to content

Definitions related to Symmetry versus Point Group #646

Description

@argerlt

I think orix would benefit from some stricter terminology constraints in the Symmetry module.

In #563 , we are talking about adding a PointGroups class which is a collection of Symmetry lists, but Symmetry has a docstring that starts with:

The set of rotations comprising a point group.

similarly, osm.get_point_group returns a Symmetry object, which is confusing if we add a PointGroups class.

In my mind, Symmetry is just the concept of rotational and/or mirror operations, so for example a five-fold symmetry is allowed. A Point Group is a more specific term, referring just to symmetries possible in a crystal. This distinction is small peanuts now, but important if we start talking about Specimen symmetry in the future (which we should).

One possible implementation is:

class PointGroup(Symmetry)
--> just symmetry, but with Schoenflies names and required to be crystallographicall possible.

class PointGroupList(PointGroup)
--> mimics the concept of PhaseList. Includes functions to return interesting lists described in #563, like:
        - proper
        - laue
        - proper_permutations

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions