You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
docs(validation): refresh stale issue states in §5.1/§5.2 (#32/#33/#36 → CLOSED) (#126)
The §5.1 cross-validation findings table labelled #32, #33, and #36 as OPEN,
but all three are now closed — and the just-merged §5.8 correctly states #33
CLOSED, so §5.1 read as an internal contradiction. Refresh each row's State to
CLOSED with an accurate close note (no fabrication; close reasons verified):
- #32: fork defect fixed+proven FAIL→PASS on arbitrum/base/avalanche (§5.6);
residual is the upstream #83-family column gap (honest NULL, not fabrication).
- #33: not a reorg (third-party-confirmed canonical blocks); closed 2026-07-04
by the 409 fork negotiation (§5.8 (B)); stream path stays experimental.
- #36: fork-side root cause (tail-chunk child-registry re-seed dropped children
below the floor), fixed on main.
Also update the §5.2 "#33 remains open" line to reflect the close.
#27 and #23 remain correctly OPEN. Docs-only.
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
|[#27](../../issues/27)| OPEN | RPC-mode realtime stores `access_list` as **NULL** for realtime-ingested typed txs — **including txs that had a real access list on chain**. Upstream Ponder tolerates a provider that omits the `accessList` key and persists NULL permanently. The Portal `/stream` leg **preserves** the access list. | Leg-A defect. Third-party confirmed via an independent public node; the Portal leg matches the real on-chain access list. Loud-fail hardening for the provider-omits-key case landed via **[#31](../../issues/31)** (merged). |
1097
-
|[#32](../../issues/32)|OPEN| A **single** transaction with a **fabricated-empty**`access_list` (`[]`) in one of two independently-synced stores (chain 42161). | A single anomalous row surfaced by the differ; pinned as a known-bad row (see §5.3) so it does not mask new drift. **Update:** the Portal *historical-backfill* fork side no longer fabricates `"[]"` for a dropped `access_list` column — [#110](../../pull/110)/[#111](../../pull/111) store honest **NULL** instead (§5.6). The Layer-E Portal-vs-RPC comparison also shows this shape is **systematic on arbitrum**, not a single row (§5.6), so #32's single-hash pin under-covers; #32stays OPEN for the upstream column gap. |
1098
-
|[#36](../../issues/36)|OPEN| RPC-mode realtime store **missing on-chain logs** (and block rows) of long-established addresses at **scattered recent blocks** — the loss is `(block, address)`-scoped. The Portal store is **complete**. | Leg-A defect. Third-party confirmed; the Portal leg holds the missing rows. |
1097
+
|[#32](../../issues/32)|CLOSED| A **single** transaction with a **fabricated-empty**`access_list` (`[]`) in one of two independently-synced stores (chain 42161). | A single anomalous row surfaced by the differ; pinned as a known-bad row (see §5.3) so it does not mask new drift. **Update:** the Portal *historical-backfill* fork side no longer fabricates `"[]"` for a dropped `access_list` column — [#110](../../pull/110)/[#111](../../pull/111) store honest **NULL** instead (§5.6). The Layer-E Portal-vs-RPC comparison also shows this shape is **systematic on arbitrum**, not a single row (§5.6), so #32's single-hash pin under-covers. **#32is now CLOSED** — the fork defect is fixed and proven **FAIL→PASS on all three affected chains** (arbitrum/base/avalanche, §5.6); the residual Portal-`NULL`-vs-RPC-populated divergence is the upstream #83-family column gap (honest NULL now, not fabrication). |
1098
+
|[#36](../../issues/36)|CLOSED| RPC-mode realtime store **missing on-chain logs** (and block rows) of long-established addresses at **scattered recent blocks** — the loss is `(block, address)`-scoped. The Portal store is **complete**. | Leg-A defect. Third-party confirmed; the Portal leg holds the missing rows. **CLOSED** — root cause identified as fork-side/client-side (leg A ran `0.16.6-sqd.1`, predating two interacting fixes: on restart the in-memory child registry re-seeded only from the tail chunk's floor, so children registered **below** it went unmatched and their rows were dropped while the interval still read complete), fixed on `main`. |
1099
1099
|[#23](../../issues/23)| OPEN | RPC-mode realtime **deterministic crash** when a single block's full-block `eth_getLogs` response exceeds viem's 10 MiB body cap (dense blocks). The Portal `/stream` leg streams through such blocks. | Leg-A (RPC transport) failure mode; documented as an objective datapoint where the Portal path is more robust. |
1100
-
|[#33](../../issues/33)|OPEN| Stream-realtime: a canonical block fataled with "unknown parent" where the parent **was** the canonical block at N−1 (no reorg involved). | Stream-realtime robustness finding on the **Portal** leg — recorded openly. Part of the stream-realtime hardening tracked by PR #26 and follow-ups; the stream path is under an experimental label until closed out. |
1100
+
|[#33](../../issues/33)|CLOSED| Stream-realtime: a canonical block fataled with "unknown parent" where the parent **was** the canonical block at N−1 (no reorg involved). | Stream-realtime robustness finding on the **Portal** leg — **not a reorg** (third-party-confirmed the fatals were on canonical blocks). **CLOSED 2026-07-04**by the 409 delivered-hash-ring / step-down fork negotiation (§5.8 (B)); the stream path remains under an experimental label. |
1101
1101
1102
1102
Two closed items for completeness:
1103
1103
@@ -1111,7 +1111,8 @@ Two closed items for completeness:
1111
1111
PR **[#26](../../pull/26)** (merged 2026-07-04) landed a wave of stream-realtime correctness fixes:
1112
1112
same-block child logs, a finality anchor, reorg pruning of factory children, a finalized-head pin, and
1113
1113
population of parent transactions on the stream wire. The realtime path continues to be treated as
1114
-
**experimental** pending the longer soak; #33 remains open against it.
1114
+
**experimental** pending the longer soak; [#33](../../issues/33) (the false-`unknown-parent` fatal it
1115
+
hardened against — **not a reorg**) is now **closed** (§5.8).
0 commit comments