Skip to content
Draft
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
Show all changes
87 commits
Select commit Hold shift + click to select a range
cb7e2f6
docs: initialize GSD planning for Linux/WSL2 milestone
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
c2ee993
docs: define v1 requirements for Linux/WSL2 support
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
5d0b56f
docs: create roadmap (4 phases, 23 requirements)
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
212c8eb
docs(01-os-detection-config): create phase plan
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
aedcfb8
chore(01-02): extend cleandeep allowed-tools with Linux commands
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
c90d950
feat(01-04): extend audit allowed-tools with Linux commands
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
474d570
feat(01-03): extend cleanquick allowed-tools with Linux commands
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
cbc8d03
feat(01-01): extend allowed-tools frontmatter with Linux commands
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
440ddc8
feat(01-05): extend update allowed-tools with Linux commands + bump v…
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
738bb29
feat(01-04): insert OS detection snippet into audit skill
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
e907a18
feat(01-05): insert OS detection snippet into update skill
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
b422591
feat(01-01): insert OS detection snippet before Mode Selection
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
1928af2
feat(01-02): insert OS detection snippet into cleandeep before Phase 1
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
ab91757
feat(01-03): insert OS detection + macOS guards in cleanquick
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
b42f941
feat(01-05): gate mas and softwareupdate on OS_TYPE in update skill
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
361e3cc
feat(01-04): guard macOS-only audit phases with OS_TYPE check
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
ac93a75
feat(01-02): guard macOS-only cleandeep phases (2, 4, 5, 6, 11, 14)
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
237bf77
feat(01-01): guard macOS-only phases and Update Mode mas/softwareupdate
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
0bd21de
docs(01-03): complete cleanquick OS detection plan
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
c061463
docs(01-04): complete audit OS detection plan — Phase 1 complete
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
2687afa
docs(01-02): complete cleandeep OS detection plan — SUMMARY + state u…
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
99f68e1
docs(01-01): complete router skill OS detection plan
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
07fdafe
docs(01-05): complete update skill OS detection plan
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
6a21ad5
docs(phase-1): complete phase execution — OS Detection & Config verified
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
b7280c0
docs(02): smart discuss context — Linux cleanup (infrastructure phase)
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
10a3037
feat(02-01): add Linux baseline branch to cleandeep Phase 1
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
9897309
feat(02-05): add Linux baseline branch to audit Phase 1
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
568408f
feat(02-05): replace Phase 2 macOS-only skip with Linux package report
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
5c72160
feat(02-01): replace Phase 2 skip guard with Linux package cache body
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
f2ee3bf
feat(02-linux-cleanup-04): add Linux support to cleanquick Phase 2 an…
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
3f71023
feat(02-05): add Linux cache, journal, snap/flatpak reporting to audi…
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
5dc58aa
docs(02-01): complete Linux cleandeep Phase 1+2 plan
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
4d0f406
docs(02-linux-cleanup-04): complete cleanquick Linux Phase 2+3 plan
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
c673bf6
docs(02-linux-cleanup-04): mark LNX-07 complete in REQUIREMENTS.md
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
9335c7b
docs(02-05): complete Linux audit reporting plan
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
76b591f
feat(02-02): add Linux user cache approval flow to cleandeep Phase 3
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
3be13dc
feat(02-02): add journalctl vacuum to cleandeep Phase 9 with macOS guard
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
e53b236
docs(02-02): complete Linux user cache and journal cleanup plan
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
4e161c4
feat(02-03): add Phase 16 Snap & Flatpak cleanup to cleandeep (Linux/…
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
92341a6
feat(02-03): add Phase 16 row to cleandeep Final Summary table
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
a137798
docs(02-03): complete Snap & Flatpak cleanup plan — cleandeep Phase 16
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
46fee93
docs(phase-02): complete phase execution — 8/8 requirements verified
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
0096de7
docs(phase-02): evolve PROJECT.md after phase 2 completion
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
530216a
docs(03): smart discuss context for WSL2 support phase
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
a2fd27a
docs(03): add WSL2 support plans — 3 plans, 1 wave, all parallel
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
37c1087
feat(03-02): add WSL2 banner to cleandeep Environment Detection
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
6d8acf4
feat(03-03): add WSL2 banner and winget/scoop/choco to update allowed…
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
578d628
feat(03-01): add WSL2 environment banner to cleanquick, audit, and up…
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
ed23cf4
feat(03-03): add Windows package manager detection block to Step 2 (W…
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
13b2935
feat(03-02): add Phase 17 Windows Temp Cleanup (WSL2 only) to cleandeep
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
5d4c868
feat(03-02): add Phase 18 Windows npm/pip Cache Audit (WSL2 only) to …
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
1ac6ad6
feat(03-02): extend cleandeep Final Summary table with Phase 17 and 1…
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
0bb51ba
feat(03-03): add Windows Packages to Step 3 table, Step 5 note, Step …
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
26af764
docs(03-01): complete WSL2 banner plan — summary, state, roadmap updated
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
04b077d
docs(03-02): complete cleandeep WSL2 phases plan
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
f76cdc0
docs(03-03): complete Windows package manager audit plan — WSL-01 + W…
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
43f7631
docs(phase-03): complete phase execution — 7/7 requirements verified
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
d2ab47c
docs(phase-03): evolve PROJECT.md after phase 3 completion
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
6a43741
docs(04): smart discuss context for update skill and polish phase
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
d7d43f7
docs(04): add update skill and polish plans — 2 plans, 1 wave, all pa…
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
28595d6
feat(04-01): split mas/softwareupdate skip notes into per-tool visibl…
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
fac1c42
feat(04-02): update upkeep router SKILL.md for cross-platform (CFG-02)
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
112eb7e
feat(04-01): add Linux apt/dnf/pacman upgrade section to Step 5 (UPD-01)
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
85d14d8
feat(04-02): update README subtitle, badges, and prerequisites for cr…
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
089a058
feat(04-01): add snap refresh and flatpak update sections to Step 5 (…
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
66c591c
feat(04-02): add Platform Support section and annotate Cleanup Catego…
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
b98037a
docs(04-02): update Test Coverage section for cross-platform scope
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
2694cd9
docs(04-01): complete Linux upgrade paths plan — UPD-01 through UPD-04
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
de856af
docs(04-02): complete cross-platform documentation polish plan
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
7d93b9f
fix(04): split combined mas+softwareupdate skip echo into per-tool li…
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
f4d511d
docs(phase-04): complete phase execution — 6/6 requirements verified
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
4fec49f
docs(phase-04): evolve PROJECT.md — all active requirements validated
KyleNesium Apr 17, 2026
74bf89b
docs(roadmap): add gap closure phases 5-6 for umbrella router parity
KyleNesium Apr 18, 2026
c934853
fix(05-01): Task 1 — OS-branch Phase 1 baseline + cross-platform stat…
KyleNesium Apr 18, 2026
9ddcec7
fix(05-01): Task 2 — add Linux/WSL2 package cache body to Phase 2
KyleNesium Apr 18, 2026
f0d1180
fix(05-01): Task 3 — add journalctl block + macOS guard to Phase 9
KyleNesium Apr 18, 2026
8fb7769
fix(05-01): Task 4 — insert Phases 16/17/18 + update Reporting table
KyleNesium Apr 18, 2026
1c12b88
fix(05): port Linux/WSL2 cleanup phases 1/2/9/16-18 to umbrella router
KyleNesium Apr 18, 2026
8b5642b
feat(06-01): Task 1+2 — WSL2 Windows pkg detection + overview table u…
KyleNesium Apr 19, 2026
b7b52d2
feat(06-01): Task 3 — add Linux PKG_MGR, snap, flatpak to Update Mode…
KyleNesium Apr 19, 2026
9df68a9
docs(06-01): complete umbrella Update Mode Linux parity plan
KyleNesium Apr 19, 2026
5b1c1f1
docs(phase-6): complete phase execution — umbrella Update Mode Linux …
KyleNesium Apr 19, 2026
0e08f8d
docs(phase-5): add verification report — 8/8 passed (umbrella cleanup…
KyleNesium Apr 19, 2026
aa77a62
docs: update v1.0 milestone audit — verdict passed (all gaps closed)
KyleNesium Apr 19, 2026
0c46960
chore: complete v1.0 milestone — Linux & WSL2 Cross-Platform Support
KyleNesium Apr 19, 2026
ed650bf
docs: add missing phase PLAN.md files for phases 02, 05, and 06
KyleNesium Apr 20, 2026
0747530
fix: add OS guard to cleanquick Phase 1 and update README privacy policy
KyleNesium Apr 20, 2026
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
1 change: 0 additions & 1 deletion .gitignore
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -1,6 +1,5 @@
.DS_Store
*.log
.planning/

# Update mode timestamp file (tracks last passive update check)
.last-update-check
Expand Down
20 changes: 20 additions & 0 deletions .planning/MILESTONES.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,20 @@
# Milestones

## v1.0 Linux & WSL2 Cross-Platform Support (Shipped: 2026-04-19)

**Phases completed:** 6 phases, 17 plans
**Timeline:** 2026-04-16 → 2026-04-19 (4 days)
**Files changed:** 64 files, ~10,950 lines added

**Key accomplishments:**

1. All 5 upkeep skills detect OS/distro at runtime via shared `$OS_TYPE`/`$PKG_MGR` environment detection snippet — macOS-only phases skip gracefully on Linux/WSL2
2. cleandeep, cleanquick, and audit deliver complete Linux cleanup (apt/dnf/pacman cache, journald vacuum, ~/.cache sweep, Snap & Flatpak orphan removal)
3. WSL2 environment detected with banner; Windows-side temp and npm/pip cache cleanup offered via `/mnt/c/` bridge
4. update skill routes to Linux package managers (apt/dnf/pacman/snap/flatpak) with per-tool confirmation gates; Windows pkg managers audited in WSL2 (audit-only, no auto-upgrade)
5. Umbrella router (`/upkeep`) fully ported — 5 integration gaps (MISS-1 through MISS-5) closed, delivering same Linux/WSL2 experience as dedicated sub-skills
6. README, badges, and descriptions updated to reflect macOS 14+ / Linux / WSL2 support across all distro families

**Archive:** `.planning/milestones/v1.0-ROADMAP.md`

---
77 changes: 77 additions & 0 deletions .planning/PROJECT.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,77 @@
# upkeep

## What This Is

upkeep is a Claude Code skill plugin that does discovery-based system cleanup and package updates. It runs on macOS 14+, Linux (Debian/Ubuntu, Fedora/RHEL, Arch), and WSL2 — routing to the right cleanup phases and package managers based on detected environment.

## Core Value

Every upkeep command gracefully handles macOS, Linux, and WSL2 without errors, skipping unavailable phases rather than failing.

## Requirements

### Validated

- ✓ macOS deep clean (15-phase audit + cleanup) — v1.0.x (pre-milestone)
- ✓ Quick cleanup (caches + brew) — v1.0.x (pre-milestone)
- ✓ Audit mode (report only, no changes) — v1.0.x (pre-milestone)
- ✓ Update skill (git-based skills + package managers) — v1.0.x (pre-milestone)
- ✓ Discovery-based orphan detection — v1.0.x (pre-milestone)
- ✓ OS detection utility shared across all skills (macOS / Linux / WSL2) — v1.0
- ✓ Linux-specific cleanup phases (apt/dnf/pacman cache, journald, ~/.cache, snap, flatpak) — v1.0
- ✓ All SKILL.md allowed-tools updated with Linux commands — v1.0
- ✓ WSL2 detection and Windows-side cleanup via /mnt/c/ bridge — v1.0
- ✓ Linux package manager support in update skill (apt, dnf, pacman, snap, flatpak) — v1.0
- ✓ README, badges, and SKILL.md descriptions reflect cross-platform support — v1.0
- ✓ Umbrella router `/upkeep` delivers same Linux/WSL2 experience as dedicated sub-skills — v1.0

### Active

(No active requirements — planning next milestone)

### Out of Scope

- Windows native (CMD/PowerShell) — not a target; WSL2 is the Windows story
- FreeBSD / other Unix — defer; focus on Linux distros and WSL2
- GUI / desktop notifications — skill is terminal-only by design
- Automated (cron) mode — not in scope for this milestone
- AUR helpers (yay/paru) — deferred to v2
- AppImage audit/cleanup — deferred to v2
- Wayland/X11 session cache cleanup — deferred to v2
- Windows Recycle Bin via WSL2 — deferred to v2
- WSL2 distro export/import size management — deferred to v2

## Context

upkeep skills are markdown files consumed by Claude Code. The "code" is Claude's instruction set, not shell scripts. OS awareness is implemented as:
1. OS detection bash snippets at the top of each skill (`$OS_TYPE`, `$OS_DISTRO`, `$PKG_MGR`)
2. macOS-specific phases wrapped in OS guards (skip gracefully on Linux/WSL2)
3. Linux-equivalent phase sections added after macOS guards
4. SKILL.md `allowed-tools` frontmatter updated with Linux commands

**Shipped v1.0:** 5 skill files, 64 files changed, ~10,950 lines across 6 phases.

**Tech stack:** Pure markdown SKILL.md instruction files. No build step, no runtime. Consumed by Claude Code `allowed-tools` frontmatter.

## Key Decisions

| Decision | Rationale | Outcome |
|----------|-----------|---------|
| OS detection at phase entry, not per-command | Cleaner skill instructions; phases self-skip rather than every command being guarded | ✓ Good — consistent pattern across all 5 skills |
| Shared OS detection snippet per skill (not a shared file) | Skills are standalone — can't `source` a shared file in Claude Code skill context | ✓ Good — each skill is self-contained |
| WSL2 treated as Linux + Windows extras | WSL2 runs Linux; build on Linux support then add Windows-side bonus cleanup | ✓ Good — layered cleanly |
| Linux distro support: Debian/Ubuntu (apt), Fedora/RHEL (dnf), Arch (pacman) | Covers ~90% of Linux desktop users; others get graceful skips | ✓ Good — covers target audience |
| sudo upgrade surfaced as Manual Steps prose only | Skill never runs sudo; consistency with existing safety rule | ✓ Good — safety preserved |
| snap/flatpak gated by `command -v`, not `$OS_TYPE` | Handles rare non-Linux installs (Homebrew Linuxbrew, etc.) | ✓ Good — more robust |
| Umbrella router phases embedded inline (not sub-skill calls) | Claude Code skills are standalone; can't delegate to other skills mid-execution | ✓ Good — no runtime coupling |
| Gap closure phases 5+6 added after initial audit | Initial 4 phases targeted sub-skills only; umbrella needed separate pass | ✓ Good — audit caught the gap; gap closure closed it |

## Constraints

- **Compatibility**: Must not break existing macOS behavior — all changes are additive guards, not replacements
- **No sudo**: Skill never runs sudo; applies to Linux too; upgrade commands shown as Manual Steps prose only
- **Skill format**: Implementation lives in SKILL.md instruction files, not shell scripts
- **Approval gates**: Any removal operations still require user confirmation (existing pattern)

---
*Last updated: 2026-04-19 after v1.0 milestone — Linux & WSL2 Cross-Platform Support shipped*
60 changes: 60 additions & 0 deletions .planning/RETROSPECTIVE.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,60 @@
# Retrospective

## Milestone: v1.0 — Linux & WSL2 Cross-Platform Support

**Shipped:** 2026-04-19
**Phases:** 6 | **Plans:** 17 | **Timeline:** 4 days (2026-04-16 → 2026-04-19)

### What Was Built

- OS detection snippet injected into all 5 SKILL.md files — `$OS_TYPE`, `$OS_DISTRO`, `$PKG_MGR` resolved at phase entry
- Linux cleanup suite (apt/dnf/pacman cache, journald vacuum, ~/.cache sweep, snap/flatpak orphans) in cleandeep, cleanquick, audit
- WSL2 detection banner + Windows-side cleanup via `/mnt/c/` bridge (Temp, npm cache, pip cache)
- Linux upgrade paths in update skill (apt/dnf/pacman + snap + flatpak); Windows pkg audit in WSL2 (winget/scoop/choco, audit-only)
- Full umbrella router parity via gap closure Phases 5+6 — all 5 integration gaps (MISS-1 through MISS-5) closed
- README, badges, and SKILL.md descriptions updated to reflect macOS 14+ / Linux / WSL2

### What Worked

- **Phase-by-phase verification** caught the umbrella gap early — the v1.0 audit surfaced MISS-1 through MISS-5 before the milestone was declared complete
- **Additive-only constraint** ("never replace, only guard") kept macOS regressions at zero — every change wrapped in an OS guard
- **Port-from-sub-skill pattern** for Phases 5+6 was safe and fast — no new logic invented, content verified against known-good source
- **`command -v` snap/flatpak gating** (not OS_TYPE) correctly handles edge cases like Linuxbrew on macOS without over-specifying

### What Was Inefficient

- **Umbrella gap discovered post-execution**: Phases 1–4 all targeted sub-skills exclusively. The umbrella router (`upkeep/skills/upkeep/SKILL.md`) was self-contained and needed its own pass. Two additional phases (5+6) were required to close the gap — this could have been anticipated in the initial roadmap.
- **Phase 5 missing VERIFICATION.md**: Phase 5 was executed via direct agent spawn, bypassing the `gsd:execute-phase` workflow which auto-runs `gsd-verifier`. The verification had to be spawned inline during the audit pass.
- **Summary one_liner field absent**: SUMMARY.md files lacked a `one_liner` frontmatter field, causing `gsd-tools summary-extract` to return null for all files. Accomplishments had to be written manually.

### Patterns Established

- **Umbrella-first rule**: In future multi-file skills, include the umbrella router in every phase plan — not as an afterthought. It doesn't inherit sub-skill changes.
- **OS guard position**: Guards placed BEFORE `command -v` checks so macOS falls through to existing tool-availability checks unchanged.
- **sudo as Manual Steps**: Upgrade commands that require sudo appear only in prose blockquote/Manual Steps sections, never in executable bash fences.
- **WSL2 `/mnt/c` outer guard**: All Windows-side operations wrapped in `if [ -d "/mnt/c" ]` outer guard to prevent path stat errors surfacing to users.

### Key Lessons

- **Umbrella routers need their own execution plan** — they don't inherit from sub-skills
- **Phase verifications should always go through execute-phase workflow** to ensure VERIFICATION.md is auto-created
- **Add `one_liner` to SUMMARY.md template** so gsd-tools can extract accomplishments automatically
- **Audit before complete** paid off — caught a high-severity gap (MISS-2, MISS-5) that would have shipped broken Linux support

### Cost Observations

- Sessions: Multiple (context-compacted mid-milestone)
- Notable: Phase 6 had 87 edit operations in one plan (the umbrella Update Mode is large); still completed in one agent execution

---

## Cross-Milestone Trends

| Metric | v1.0 |
|--------|------|
| Phases | 6 |
| Plans | 17 |
| Timeline | 4 days |
| Audit gaps found | 5 |
| Audit gaps closed | 5 |
| Regression count | 0 |
32 changes: 32 additions & 0 deletions .planning/ROADMAP.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,32 @@
# Roadmap: upkeep

## Milestones

- ✅ **v1.0 Linux & WSL2 Cross-Platform Support** — Phases 1–6 (shipped 2026-04-19)

## Phases

<details>
<summary>✅ v1.0 Linux & WSL2 Cross-Platform Support (Phases 1–6) — SHIPPED 2026-04-19</summary>

- [x] Phase 1: OS Detection & Config (5/5 plans) — completed 2026-04-17
- [x] Phase 2: Linux Cleanup (5/5 plans) — completed 2026-04-17
- [x] Phase 3: WSL2 Support (3/3 plans) — completed 2026-04-17
- [x] Phase 4: Update Skill & Polish (2/2 plans) — completed 2026-04-17
- [x] Phase 5: Umbrella Router — Linux Cleanup Phase Parity (1/1 plan) — completed 2026-04-18
- [x] Phase 6: Umbrella Router — Update Mode Linux Parity (1/1 plan) — completed 2026-04-19

Full details: `.planning/milestones/v1.0-ROADMAP.md`

</details>

## Progress

| Phase | Milestone | Plans Complete | Status | Completed |
|-------|-----------|----------------|--------|-----------|
| 1. OS Detection & Config | v1.0 | 5/5 | Complete | 2026-04-17 |
| 2. Linux Cleanup | v1.0 | 5/5 | Complete | 2026-04-17 |
| 3. WSL2 Support | v1.0 | 3/3 | Complete | 2026-04-17 |
| 4. Update Skill & Polish | v1.0 | 2/2 | Complete | 2026-04-17 |
| 5. Umbrella Router — Linux Cleanup Phase Parity | v1.0 | 1/1 | Complete | 2026-04-18 |
| 6. Umbrella Router — Update Mode Linux Parity | v1.0 | 1/1 | Complete | 2026-04-19 |
46 changes: 46 additions & 0 deletions .planning/STATE.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,46 @@
---
gsd_state_version: 1.0
milestone: v1.0
milestone_name: Linux & WSL2 Cross-Platform Support
status: complete
stopped_at: Milestone v1.0 complete — shipped 2026-04-19
last_updated: "2026-04-19T00:00:00.000Z"
progress:
total_phases: 6
completed_phases: 6
total_plans: 17
completed_plans: 17
---

# Project State

## Project Reference

See: .planning/PROJECT.md (updated 2026-04-19)

**Core value:** Every upkeep command gracefully handles macOS, Linux, and WSL2 without errors
**Current focus:** v1.0 shipped — planning next milestone

## Current Position

Milestone v1.0 complete. All 6 phases, 17 plans shipped and verified.

## Accumulated Context

### Key Decisions

Logged in PROJECT.md Key Decisions table.

### Pending Todos

None.

### Blockers/Concerns

None.

## Session Continuity

Last session: 2026-04-19
Stopped at: Milestone v1.0 complete
Resume file: None
15 changes: 15 additions & 0 deletions .planning/config.json
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,15 @@
{
"mode": "yolo",
"granularity": "coarse",
"parallelization": true,
"commit_docs": true,
"model_profile": "balanced",
"workflow": {
"research": false,
"plan_check": true,
"verifier": true,
"nyquist_validation": false,
"auto_advance": false,
"_auto_chain_active": false
}
}
123 changes: 123 additions & 0 deletions .planning/milestones/v1.0-MILESTONE-AUDIT.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,123 @@
---
milestone: v1.0 — Linux & WSL2 Cross-Platform Support
audited: 2026-04-19
phases: 6
requirements_total: 23
requirements_satisfied: 23
integration_gaps: 0
minor_findings: 4
tech_debt_items: 2
verdict: passed
---

# Milestone Audit: v1.0 — Linux & WSL2 Cross-Platform Support

**Audited:** 2026-04-19 (re-audit after gap closure)
**Phases audited:** 6 of 6 (all complete, all phase verifications passed)
**Requirements:** 23/23 satisfied
**Verdict:** `passed` — all requirements satisfied; umbrella router fully updated; no blocking gaps

---

## 1. Requirements Coverage

All 23 v1 requirements satisfied across all 6 phases:

| Phase | Requirements | Status |
|-------|-------------|--------|
| Phase 1: OS Detection & Config | OS-01, OS-02, OS-03, OS-04, CFG-01 | ✓ All satisfied |
| Phase 2: Linux Cleanup | LNX-01–08 | ✓ All satisfied |
| Phase 3: WSL2 Support | WSL-01–04 | ✓ All satisfied |
| Phase 4: Update Skill & Polish | UPD-01–04, CFG-02, CFG-03 | ✓ All satisfied |
| Phase 5: Umbrella Cleanup Parity | OS-01, LNX-01, LNX-02, LNX-04, LNX-05, LNX-06, WSL-02, WSL-03 | ✓ All satisfied (umbrella) |
| Phase 6: Umbrella Update Parity | UPD-01, UPD-02, UPD-03, WSL-04 | ✓ All satisfied (umbrella) |

**Coverage: 23/23 — no unmapped requirements.**

---

## 2. Phase Verification Summary

| Phase | Score | Status | Notes |
|-------|-------|--------|-------|
| 01-os-detection-config | All must-haves | passed | |
| 02-linux-cleanup | All must-haves | passed | |
| 03-wsl2-support | All must-haves | passed | |
| 04-update-skill-polish | 6/6 | passed | UPD-04 gap closed inline |
| 05-umbrella-cleanup-parity | 8/8 | passed | Phase 1/2/9/16/17/18 all wired |
| 06-umbrella-update-parity | 7/7 | passed | Step 2/3/5/6 all wired |

---

## 3. Integration Check

**Result: `passed`** — All 23 requirements are wired end-to-end through the umbrella router.

### E2E Flows Verified

| Flow | Entry Point | Status |
|------|-------------|--------|
| Ubuntu deep clean (`/upkeep deep`) | `upkeep/skills/upkeep/SKILL.md` | PASS — Phase 1 Linux baseline → Phase 2 apt cache → Phase 9 journalctl → Phase 16 snap/flatpak all present |
| Linux system update (`/upkeep update`) | `upkeep/skills/upkeep/SKILL.md` | PASS — Step 5 $PKG_MGR dispatch (apt/dnf/pacman) + snap refresh + flatpak update all wired |
| WSL2 deep clean (`/upkeep deep` in WSL2) | `upkeep/skills/upkeep/SKILL.md` | PASS — Phase 17 Windows Temp + Phase 18 Windows npm/pip present; Step 2 WSL2 pkg detection wired |

### Minor Findings (Non-blocking, LOW/NEGLIGIBLE severity)

| ID | Severity | Location | Description |
|----|----------|----------|-------------|
| F-01 | LOW | `cleanquick/SKILL.md` Phase 1 | Linux baseline info (df, os-release, uname) not included in quick mode — Phase 1 goes straight to cleanup without environment banner equivalent on Linux |
| F-02 | LOW | `audit/SKILL.md` reporting table | Snap row absent from the audit summary table footer (snap content is present in the phase body) |
| F-03 | LOW | `upkeep/skills/upkeep/SKILL.md` Phase 3 | Umbrella ~/.cache approval gate differs slightly from cleandeep sub-skill phrasing (functional parity achieved, wording variance only) |
| F-04 | NEGLIGIBLE | Multiple sub-skill SKILL.md descriptions | `cleandeep`, `cleanquick`, `audit`, `update` sub-skill descriptions still say "macOS" in the one-liner; CFG-02 satisfied at umbrella level |

None of these findings block any primary Linux or WSL2 user path. All are candidates for v1.1 polish.

---

## 4. Gap Closure Summary (vs. v1.0 Initial Audit)

The initial audit (`audited: 2026-04-17`) found 5 integration gaps in the umbrella router. All are now closed:

| Gap | Severity | Phase Closed | Status |
|-----|----------|-------------|--------|
| MISS-1: Phase 1 Baseline — no Linux branch for sw_vers | Low | Phase 5 | ✓ Closed |
| MISS-2: Phase 2 Homebrew Audit — Linux skips with no substitute | High | Phase 5 | ✓ Closed |
| MISS-3: Phase 9 Stale Logs — no journalctl block | Medium | Phase 5 | ✓ Closed |
| MISS-4: Phases 16–18 absent | Medium | Phase 5 | ✓ Closed |
| MISS-5: Update Mode Step 5 — missing Linux upgrade paths + WSL2 pkg detection | High | Phase 6 | ✓ Closed |

---

## 5. Tech Debt (Non-blocking)

| ID | File | Location | Description | Impact |
|----|------|----------|-------------|--------|
| TD-01 | `README.md` | Lines 46–50 | "Why upkeep?" section describes only macOS pain points; cross-platform angle absent | Cosmetic — all other README sections are cross-platform |
| TD-02 | `README.md` | Lines 268, 272 | Privacy section references "standard macOS locations" and "standard macOS commands" | Accurate for macOS scope but phrasing slightly stale |

---

## 6. Deferred Work (v2)

| ID | Description | Phase Deferred In |
|----|-------------|-------------------|
| LNX-V2-01 | AUR helper updates (yay/paru) in update skill | Phase 4 |
| LNX-V2-02 | AppImage audit and cleanup | Phase 2 |
| LNX-V2-03 | Wayland/X11 session cache cleanup | Phase 2 |
| WSL-V2-01 | Windows Recycle Bin audit via WSL2 bridge | Phase 3 |
| WSL-V2-02 | WSL2 distro export/import size management | Phase 3 |

---

## 7. Verdict

**`passed`** — All 23 v1 requirements are satisfied in both the dedicated sub-skills and the umbrella router. The five integration gaps identified in the initial audit have been closed across Phases 5 and 6. Users invoking `/upkeep deep`, `/upkeep quick`, `/upkeep audit`, or `/upkeep update` on Linux or WSL2 receive the full cross-platform experience.

The 4 minor findings (F-01 through F-04) and 2 tech debt items do not block the v1.0 release — they are candidates for v1.1 polish.

---

*Initial audit: 2026-04-17 (verdict: gaps_found — 5 integration gaps)*
*Re-audit: 2026-04-19 (verdict: passed — all gaps closed)*
*Audited by: gsd-integration-checker + gsd-verifier + orchestrator*
*Source: 6x VERIFICATION.md (all passed) + REQUIREMENTS.md traceability (23/23 Complete) + integration check of upkeep/skills/upkeep/SKILL.md*
Loading